I pretty regularly check the beauty section of Craigslist for high-end makeup. It's not uncommon to see palettes and things like that advertised as brand new, never swatched for about 50% of retail costs. Mostly it's just for fun to see what people are selling, like any other window shopping. I've never actually purchased anything but I think today I might.

I wasn't born yesterday and I know it's likely that a lot of these items were stolen from retailers. As much as I try to tell myself, oh, maybe they were just gifts or whatever, probably not, right?

What do you think about this dilemma?