So my FiL has been dating his girlfriend as long as I have know Mr. I. but over the last year things really seem to have been going sour between them for many reasons. My FiL is rather horrible.

Anyways, the way he's been talking they have been on the verge of splitting up for the six months at least. Only then they don't. So I am trying to figure out if we should get her a Christmas present or not.We never see her other than in his company. She's quite nice (I wonder what the hell she is doing with him) but we are not particularly close.

Last year we gave her some nice handmade mugs, fancy hot chocolate, and a bottle of booze to go in the hot chocolate. The previous year we got both of them a gift certificate they could use for live theatre in Toronto. This year I have no clue what to get her, or even if she'll be around.

Thoughts?