I think we can all agree Baby Its Cold Out There is the least favorite of everyones so let’s exclude it. Words in that song are so problematic.
Pop Christmas songs
Favorite is Winter Wonderland by Johnny Mathis. My mother had this album when I was a kid in the 70s and always played it. I do not think I ever heard him sing other nonChristmas songs but this is the best.
Least favorite is
Paul McCartney’s Wonderful Christmas Time the only way those kids are singing their line all year long is if they want to annoy everyone around them.
God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
Beautiful song. Ideally sung by a pure soprano and a man with a deep low voice. This Loreena McKennitt version is fantastic..
Least favorite is O Come All Ye Faithful the line “be joyful and triumphant” annoys me. Who are we triumphant over.