Aka That time I was more attracted to you when you were in costume and not your alter ego.
The most common I hear is the Beast. He was way more attractive as the beast and then when he changes, it was like Oh... umm no. (Note I hold no feelings for the beast.)
Mine : Ragman in Arrow
Oh wow, listen to your weird voice. Can you just read to me in that voice? Oh you are kinda hot mister rag. I love the belts. Are you a mummy? Is it like an ancient curse? You must be like way old. Are you like Darkman?
Oh, it’s a boy in his dad’s costume. I like that your Dad saved you.... but you look like one of my students.
Hard pass. Ummm no.
What about you Groupthink?