I do not think this person is a troll (ETA: This person apparently is a troll, and I didn't realize it. I suppose that says something about the level of vitriol I am used to? In any case, they are points that people think of, and I am glad that I got to confront them. I think it's best to have it up and rebutted, given the point of the original post.) and I am not asking for help, but did I take the right tone with the response?