I’m currently listening to the OST of New Battlestar Galactica. It has always been a favorite of mine and is one of the fews scores I’m still listening to (especially season 3-4).
Maybe it’s just me, but Bear McCreary has since then never managed to come even close to the magic that is the BSG music. Everything after that has always sounded like uninspired copies. Those 4 scores represent a huge amount of music, so maybe I shouldn’t be too sad, but damn, it feels like he poured his heart and soul into this and there was nothing left for more.

What’s your favorite score?