Frizzy says, “Pet my tummy!”

My 14 year old kitty got sick this week and the vet costs are painful. I keep meaning to get insurance for my younger cat (pictured above) and this is a good motivation to do so. I’m looking at the ASPCA plan, PetFirst (cheapest), and HealthyPaws (middle). Does anyone have any experiences with pet insurance? Any recommendations? Thank you in advance!