I've realized the whole point is to be really shallow and make a snap judgment, and honestly, I've been enjoying it, because it's so different from how I normally use the site. So some guy I rated highly emailed me and said:
I must admit that any woman that enjoys Neil Gaiman has my attention.
Um...is this unusual? I know a ton of women who LOVE Neil Gaiman. You are no longer rated 4 stars, sir.