I agree Arkham Asylum is a disjointed mess also the graphics were headache inducing. I loved Kingdom Come especially about Captain Marvel how his innocence and naiveness is used against him. I would include Batman's Knightfall. The first part with Bane was excellent then the second part was sooo long especially against the serial killer who killed his relatives. Also Azrael was so unlikable and flat out insane. article I loved the Dark Phoenix Saga when it came out but I read it again a year ago and knew that Jean Grey would come back makes the impact of the Saga almost worthless. Also Scott Summers when I read it again comes across as even more insufferable then when I read it in the 1980s. I think the problem with the list is you needed to have read it then